Customer Reviews

  • LC

    “Every time we have contacted McElhinny office it has been a Great experience. We always deal with Cathy and she is the absolute best!! From changing vehicles to accidents never have been disappointed.”

  • MM
  • BB

    “Made an appt. They were able to answer all.my questions. Everybody very friendly and helpful.

  • PA

    “You are always there to answer any questions I might have about my insurance needs. I feel completely covered in the event of an accident either in my home or in my auto. The staff is very friendly and knowledgeable. Thank you McElhinny Agency for providing outstanding service. ”

  • CW

    “Excellent people and service

  • SS

    “Was pleasant to work with, quick to respond to emails, and very helpful to any questions I had. Would recommend!

  • EO

    “Excellent service- always available whe you need them !!

  • DT

    “We have been with Erie and McElhinny Insurance for 50 years. That should say it all! They care about their clients. Really an efficient group of people, thank you all!

  • “Rates are very reasonable and they responded quickly and efficiently to the claim that we submitted. They are very friendly and professional to deal with. We highly recommend using their Agency for homeowners and auto insurance.

  • GF

    “I haven’t had much in the way of dealings with my insurance regarding home owners or automobile. However recently I was involved in an accident that was completely the fault of the other driver – who did have insurance. I reached out to Erie anyhow just to go on record and they were very helpful in taking the necessary steps, just in case I would have to file with them.”

  • LV
  • RT

    “Tim has been very responsive, thoughtful and proactive in providing us great service and coverage for many years. In every circumstance he has worked to provide solutions to our business insurance needs. He is just a terrific resource for our business!

  • “The office is very helpful when calling with questions or concerns. I’ve been with them for years!

  • “I have had my insurance with this company for over 35 years. Wonderful customer service and prompt attention to my questions and needs are the reasons I have stayed with them.

  • “Prompt knowledgeable and caring personnel. Eager to assist in all insurance related matters.