- Insurance Services
- Auto, Home & Personal Insurance
- Classic Car Insurance
- Business Insurance
- Business Interruption Insurance
- Business Owners Package Insurance
- Commercial Auto Insurance
- Commercial Property Insurance
- Commercial Umbrella Insurance
- General Liability Insurance
- Hotel & Motel Hospitality Insurance
- Manufacturers Insurance
- Professional Liability (E&O) Insurance
- Surety Bonds
- Workers' Compensation Insurance
- - View All Business
- Life & Health Insurance
- About Us
- Policy Service
- Contact Us
Customer Reviews
- LMLisa M., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Very reasonable prices and explained everything in detail.”
- MCMichael C., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I know you will find that no matter who you get hold of on the phone at McElhinny Insurance Agency – and you really will find that a live person answers’ your call and not some AI voice on a revolving tape, is 100% “in synch” with each other in regards to customers and their insurance needs. I can only speak for myself but each time I called, there was NEVER a hassle and whatever I happened to need, got taken care of faster then they can pack one of those little cooked hamburgers in the cardboard box. If you know what I mean. If you ever watched that. 99% faster than booking your next hair appointment. They ARE real people. Go in and see for yourself. They are not customer service specialists trained to follow a pre-written script that is generic for everyone, or “Tech Help” so commonly known now. My family has been with McElhenny Insurance Agency for over a decade now. Stop falling for those to good to be true offers that show up in your mailbox. You Googled this. Here it is! Call them!”
- MGMatthew G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tom and Cathy are amazing! Started with auto insurance over a decade ago and have moved my home and business insurance with them now. Great service and great people.”
- TWTravis W., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tim’s a great guy and have me a great policy with a great price.”
- MSMichael S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Cathy responded in a very timely manner and was able to provide me a quote that was much better then I currently had with progressive. She also followed up on some questions I had after the sale. I will recommend her to anyone that is in need of insurance. Thank you”
- SSSamantha S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- DKDavid K., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- BBBill B., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Excellent service”
- SGSusan G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Denise was great”
- JRJoel R., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“McElhinny Insurance gives great service to his customers, we highly recommend them!”
- RIRian I., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I have been a customer with the Mcelhinny Insurance Agency for years and they have always treated me wonderful. They take the time to listen and help me with all my insurance questions. I am very happy with their service and have recommended them to my family.”
- JSJan S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Very friendly & informative, been with them for years.”
- DTDella T., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“We have been with Erie and McElhinny Insurance for 50 years. That should say it all! They care about their clients. Really an efficient group of people, thank you all!”
- GFGail F., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I haven’t had much in the way of dealings with my insurance regarding home owners or automobile. However recently I was involved in an accident that was completely the fault of the other driver – who did have insurance. I reached out to Erie anyhow just to go on record and they were very helpful in taking the necessary steps, just in case I would have to file with them.”
- SBStaci B., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I’ve been with both McElhinny and Erie Insurance for 25 years; their responsive, customer-centric service is unmatched in the industry and keeps me renewing year after year.”
