Skip to the content

Insuring the Greater Pittsburgh Area Since 1960

Insurance Services
About Us
Policy Service
Contact Us

Home > Customer Reviews

Customer Reviews

MG
Matthew G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tom and Cathy are amazing! Started with auto insurance over a decade ago and have moved my home and business insurance with them now. Great service and great people.”
TW
Travis W., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tim’s a great guy and have me a great policy with a great price.”
MS
Michael S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Cathy responded in a very timely manner and was able to provide me a quote that was much better then I currently had with progressive. She also followed up on some questions I had after the sale. I will recommend her to anyone that is in need of insurance. Thank you”
SS
Samantha S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
DK
David K., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
BB
Bill B., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Excellent service”
SG
Susan G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Denise was great”
JR
Joel R., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“McElhinny Insurance gives great service to his customers, we highly recommend them!”
RI
Rian I., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I have been a customer with the Mcelhinny Insurance Agency for years and they have always treated me wonderful. They take the time to listen and help me with all my insurance questions. I am very happy with their service and have recommended them to my family.”
JS
Jan S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Very friendly & informative, been with them for years.”
DT
Della T., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“We have been with Erie and McElhinny Insurance for 50 years. That should say it all! They care about their clients. Really an efficient group of people, thank you all!”
GF
Gail F., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I haven’t had much in the way of dealings with my insurance regarding home owners or automobile. However recently I was involved in an accident that was completely the fault of the other driver – who did have insurance. I reached out to Erie anyhow just to go on record and they were very helpful in taking the necessary steps, just in case I would have to file with them.”
SB
Staci B., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I’ve been with both McElhinny and Erie Insurance for 25 years; their responsive, customer-centric service is unmatched in the industry and keeps me renewing year after year.”
RT
Rich T., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tim has been very responsive, thoughtful and proactive in providing us great service and coverage for many years. In every circumstance he has worked to provide solutions to our business insurance needs. He is just a terrific resource for our business!”
LV
Lam V., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

Previous Page
1
2
…
18
Next Page

McElhinny Insurance Agency

Rated 5 out of 5 based on 123 rated reviews.

We Want Your Opinion!

Pittsburgh Insurance Quotes

Email
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
Email*
Phone (Optional)
Select Type of Insurance*

Δ

About Us

About Us
Meet Our Staff
Our Insurance Carriers
Customer Reviews
Insurance Blog

Insurance

Auto Insurance
Classic Car Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life & Health Insurance

Policy Service

Policy Service Center
File A Claim
Online Billing & Payments
Policy Change Request
Annual Insurance Checklist

Connect With Us

Google Maps Logo (opens in new tab)Yelp Logo (opens in new tab)Facebook Logo (opens in new tab)X Logo (opens in new tab)LinkedIn Logo (opens in new tab)YouTube Logo (opens in new tab)Instagram Logo (opens in new tab)Nextdoor Logo (opens in new tab)

Get Directions (opens in new tab)

McElhinny Insurance Agency

5624 Brownsville Road
Second Floor
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15236

Phone: (412) 650-5700

Fax: (412) 650-5782

Office Hours
Mon-Fri: 9:00am-5:00pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

McElhinny Insurance Agency Provides Auto Insurance, Classic Car Insurance, Home Insurance, Small Business Insurance & Life Insurance to All of Pennsylvania, Including Pittsburgh, Jefferson Hills, and Mt. Lebanon.

© Copyright 2026, McElhinny Insurance Agency | Privacy Statement | Accessibility Statement | Login

Website Builder Platform(opens in new tab)