Customer Reviews

  • LP

    “20 plus years of personal service unequaled. ”

  • ED

    “Erie insurance was there when I needed them. They were helpful and understanding. Plus, keeping insured. Thanks very much. ”

  • SM

    “Best Insurance ever ”

  • KM

    “Will take the time to answer all questions and explain things that I / we don’t fully understand.

    Supports the local community!

  • MK

    “Great service with quick and accurate answers!”

  • EB

    “You always let us know when we get discounts”

  • ED

    “You were great when I had my accident. Just wonderful to me when I needed the help. Thanks again. ”

  • SF

    “Great customer service ”

  • DF

    “Outstanding service when needed”

  • CS

    “In my experience, everyone is very responsive to inquiries and information. I find it very valuable for you folks to be so accessible!”

  • JM

    “The staff is knowledgeable and helpful. The owner gives useful advice and guidance. ”

  • DM

    “You always following through answering my questions and resolving problems.”

  • CP

    “I have NEVER had any other insurance company. (over 40) I haven’t even had a problem with McElhinny any accident or event that was cover by erie was handled with speed with a fair and honest settlement. My work and wives job both offered us insurance and most of the times its cheaper but for the amount I would save I rather have the piece of mind knowing if I have a problem I wont have jump through hoops trying to get it handled. Thank you McElhinny and don’t change a thing!!”

  • WB

    “React quickly to any requests.”

  • RB

    “Quick response to questions and support when needed.”