- Insurance Services
- Auto, Home & Personal Insurance
- Classic Car Insurance
- Business Insurance
- Business Interruption Insurance
- Business Owners Package Insurance
- Commercial Auto Insurance
- Commercial Property Insurance
- Commercial Umbrella Insurance
- General Liability Insurance
- Hotel & Motel Hospitality Insurance
- Manufacturers Insurance
- Professional Liability (E&O) Insurance
- Surety Bonds
- Workers' Compensation Insurance
- - View All Business
- Life & Health Insurance
- About Us
- Policy Service
- Contact Us
Customer Reviews
- Great people who knows their business.Mz M., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
- Great staff to deal with.Sylvia B., Pittsburgh, PA
- Great Agency, ...Rich K., Pittsburgh, PA
“Great Agency, always takes care of my needs and quickly responds in all situations.”
- JMI have always received excellent service from the people at McElhinnyAnonymous, Pittsburgh, PA
“I have always received excellent service from the people at McElhinny Insurance. Denise is always so friendly and takes the time to explain the details about the policy and help me decide what makes sense for me to add or drop from my policy. Her honesty is why I could never see myself choosing a different agent.”
- HBPrompt and professional service always friendly and helpful goodPittsburgh, PA
“Prompt and professional service
always friendly and helpful
good people.”
- LRVery professional and always responded in a timely manner.Jefferson Hills, PA
- RHThe one time I needed my car insurance was after a small accident in Florida.Anonymous, Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Oct 2018
“The one time I needed my car insurance was after a small accident in Florida. My agent called as soon as the agent from the other car called her. I quickly explained what happened. There was no damage to my car and I sent photos. She said she would get back to me asap. Before the end of the day I got a call that the other driver claimed that we had rear ended her. It was actually a kind of side swiped each other,barely. Since I had already sent pictures and my air bags had not deployed she told me not to worry and it was taken care of. ”
- JRYour team always handles my requests and changes promptly and efficiently.Pittsburgh, PACustomer since Jun 2011
“Your team always handles my requests and changes promptly and efficiently. The team is always very friendly.”
- Fantastic service!
- Five stars.
- MCMichael C., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“I know you will find that no matter who you get hold of on the phone at McElhinny Insurance Agency – and you really will find that a live person answers’ your call and not some AI voice on a revolving tape, is 100% “in synch” with each other in regards to customers and their insurance needs. I can only speak for myself but each time I called, there was NEVER a hassle and whatever I happened to need, got taken care of faster then they can pack one of those little cooked hamburgers in the cardboard box. If you know what I mean. If you ever watched that. 99% faster than booking your next hair appointment. They ARE real people. Go in and see for yourself. They are not customer service specialists trained to follow a pre-written script that is generic for everyone, or “Tech Help” so commonly known now. My family has been with McElhenny Insurance Agency for over a decade now. Stop falling for those to good to be true offers that show up in your mailbox. You Googled this. Here it is! Call them!”
- MGMatthew G., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tom and Cathy are amazing! Started with auto insurance over a decade ago and have moved my home and business insurance with them now. Great service and great people.”
- TWTravis W., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Tim’s a great guy and have me a great policy with a great price.”
- MSMichael S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
“Cathy responded in a very timely manner and was able to provide me a quote that was much better then I currently had with progressive. She also followed up on some questions I had after the sale. I will recommend her to anyone that is in need of insurance. Thank you”
- SSSamantha S., Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania





