Customer Reviews

  • CR

    “I love how personalized your service is! ”

  • RM

    “ I have always received prompt and excellent service from this company. I have been with them for 35 years.”

  • GI

    “I know I can trust you.”

  • RU

    “Always willing to answer the tough questions!”

  • JE

    “Excellent service.”

  • JL

    “Always receive prompt and courteous service by the staff.”

  • MP

    “We feel we have always been treated great. The women in the office are very friendly and helpful. Also, we have never had an issue with a claim. ”

  • MS

    “I have received nothing but fantastic advice from your staff when I call with questions about being able to save money on my policies. They give it to me straight with all of the options that are available to me. If customers are not taking time out to talk about how they can save money on any of their policies, then they are not interested in saving money, it’s that simple !!”

  • SG

    “I remember, as a child, when Dennis McHinney would come to our home to collect my parents insurance payment. He and my father would sit at our kitchen table and talk for hours. So, when I purchased my first car, it only seemed natural to have Erie insurance. I have been a customer for over 30 years and will remain so. My husband and I have purchased our first home. I called and spoke to Denise and together we formulated the homeowners insurance. McElhinny Erie Insurance will continue, with the 3rd generation owners, to remain our car and home insurances providers. A shout out to Denise for her continued awesome service.”

  • DF

    “Great service and staff! ”

  • CG

    “I have been with Erie Insurance for over 35 years! They have always had my back, home owners and car insurance also my kids! Any accidents or damage done to my home or cars Erie is Johnny on the spot. Received payment for damages that same week of reporting incidents. Friendly, courteous and timely service. I highly recommend McElhinny Erie Insurance company they will always have your back.
    Very satisfied!”

  • RB

    “Every time I need something or have a question about something theirs always
    someone there to answer. No machines real live people to talk to love it.”

  • JF

    “Fast service and response time to requests. Very friendly agents. ”

  • DB

    “We appreciate your service and efforts in providing us with excellent support and care for all of our business needs. ”

  • DS

    “Tom helps me with all of my business needs. Great guy!!”